By M10News Investigative Desk | January 4, 2026
DUBLIN — A growing chorus of legal, housing, and gerontology experts are warning that the Government’s upcoming rental reforms could “paralyse” thousands of families relying on the Fair Deal scheme, triggering what some describe as “one of the most foreseeable housing policy collisions in recent memory.”
From March 2026, all new tenancies will be bound by a six-year minimum term under the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2025 a measure designed to improve security of tenure for renters.
But when combined with Fair Deal’s strict requirements on property sales after a resident’s death, multiple professionals across Ireland say the two policies are “on a direct collision course.”
Policy Designed to Free Up Housing Now Threatened by Rental Law Clash
The Government’s earlier reform allowing nursing home residents and their families to keep 100% of rental income from the resident’s home was expected to bring between 3,000 and 5,000 long-vacant properties back into circulation.
A Cork-based gerontologist told M10News that the revenue exemptions were intended to help both families and the housing market:
“Fair Deal families finally had a workable incentive to rent out homes that were sitting empty. It was one of the most practical reforms introduced in years.”
But with the six-year Tenancies of Minimum Duration (TMD) kicking in from March, that optimism has evaporated.
Six-Year “Lock-In” Could Make Properties Unsellable
Under Fair Deal rules, when a resident passes away, the Nursing Home Loan often representing tens of thousands in care payments must be repaid within 12 months. Families typically rely on the sale of the home.
But under the new tenancy system:
- A family cannot terminate the tenancy just because the homeowner dies.
- Most grounds for “no-fault” eviction are now restricted or removed.
- A sitting tenant can block or severely depress a sale.
- Tenant-in-situ sales may fail to meet the HSE’s repayment deadlines.
A senior probate solicitor in Dublin told M10News:
“We are about to see families stuck in legally impossible positions. The State is promoting renting through Fair Deal while simultaneously preventing the property from being sold when the care loan comes due. You couldn’t design a worse policy clash.”
Dublin: High Demand, High Risk
In Dublin where more than 1,000 Fair Deal homes are estimated to be suitable for rental the risk is amplified by soaring property values.
A north Dublin estate agent said:
“Families in Dublin stand to lose enormous value if forced to sell with a tenant in situ. A property worth €600,000 vacant could fetch €75,000 to €100,000 less when sold occupied. Most families won’t take that risk.”
Several Dublin solicitors report a “surge of queries” from families reconsidering whether to rent out Fair Deal homes at all.
Cork: Rural/Urban Divide Deepening
In Cork, where the market is more mixed, families face an uneven landscape. Rural properties are harder to sell with sitting tenants, while city properties risk long-term entanglements.
A Cork city letting agent told M10News:
“Families are asking whether they should leave the house empty. They’re afraid of a six-year tenancy turning into a six-year legal battle.”
In West Cork and North Cork, agents say the reforms could reduce local supply, as families do not want to compromise rural inheritance properties by locking them into regulated tenancies.
Rural Counties: Vacancy Likely to Rise, Not Fall
In counties such as Mayo, Donegal, Kerry, and Roscommon, Fair Deal homes often require refurbishment or sale to settle estates. These regions already struggle with low demand for tenant-in-situ sales.
A housing policy researcher in Galway said:
“The Government hoped Fair Deal would release rural homes into the market. Instead, the new rental rules will freeze those properties into long-term vacancy. It’s an unintended but severe outcome.”
In some counties, professionals predict an increase in vacant homes the exact opposite of what Fair Deal rental reforms were meant to achieve.
Why the 12-Month Deadline Is a Flashpoint
The HSE typically requires the Nursing Home Loan to be repaid within a year. If the home cannot be sold due to a protected tenancy:
- Families may be forced to borrow significant sums.
- Interest and penalties can accumulate if repayment is late.
- Estates may become tied up in court proceedings.
A Tralee-based solicitor noted:
“We expect estate disputes to rise dramatically. This isn’t just a housing issue — it will spill into probate law, family disputes, and financial hardship.”
Restricted Eviction Rights Add Pressure
While landlords with up to three properties still retain limited rights to sell, the rules now require:
- Proof of intent
- Extended notice periods
- Compliance inspections
- Transfer of tenancy where permitted
- Documentation far beyond previous requirements
Many families will not meet these criteria.
Regional Impact at a Glance
RegionPredicted ImpactExpert InsightDublin Severe financial loss on tenant-in-situ sales; families reluctant to rent. Homes could lose €75k–€100k if sold with a sitting tenant. Cork City Families are likely to avoid new leases entirely. “Fear of entanglement outweighs rental income.” Rural Cork Increased vacancy rates.
Properties harder to sell with tenants. West of Ireland Policy could backfire entirely; homes remain empty. “Fair Deal reforms nullified by tenancy laws.” South-West (Kerry/Limerick) Strong risk of disputes and missed HSE deadlines. Solicitors expect probate delays to spike.
Potential Chilling Effect on Housing Supply
Analysts warn that the policy conflict may prevent the release of thousands of homes — worsening Ireland’s housing shortage.
A senior housing economist told M10News:
“Instead of unlocking 5,000 homes, the Government may lock down 5,000 homes. Families will not risk creating a tenancy they cannot legally unwind.”
If left unaddressed, the system could become paralysed by conflicting priorities between the Department of Housing and the Department of Health.
Government Yet to Clarify If Exemptions Are Planned
As of early January, neither department has confirmed whether Fair Deal properties will be exempted from the six-year TMD rules. Legal and housing experts say any exemption must be introduced before 1 March 2026 to avoid system-wide consequences.
M10News Transparency Note
This report draws on expert interviews, RTB data, regional estate insights, and analysis of the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2025 and Fair Deal scheme. M10News remains committed to reporting on how legislative changes impact ordinary households and vulnerable families.
M10News Investigative Desk | Contact: investigations@m10news.com
© 2026 M10News. All rights reserved. Unauthorised reproduction is prohibited
