A man wrongfully imprisoned for 17 years expressed dissatisfaction with the ‘unreserved apology’ he received, deeming it inadequate given the years he lost.
Andrew Malkinson, wrongfully convicted of rape in 2003, finally saw his conviction overturned by the Court of Appeal in July last year after maintaining his innocence throughout.
Despite the availability of crucial DNA evidence since 2007, which failed to match any in the police database, Malkinson’s appeals for a review by the Wm Cases Review Commission (CCRC) were initially denied.
Even after a second application in 2020, the outcome remained unchanged, prolonging his unjust incarceration.
The CCRC’s admission of failure in Malkinson’s, as revealed in an independent review by Chris Henley KC, led Chairwoman Helen Pitcher to offer a heartfelt apology.
However, Malkinson questioned the sincerity of the apology and urged Justice Secretary Alex Chalk to instate ‘new leadership’ within the CCRC.
In response, Pitcher emphasized the commission’s regret and expressed sympathy for the immense suffering Malkinson endured due to their mishandling of his case.
She acknowledged the profound impact of his wrongful conviction on his life and extended a sincere apology on behalf of the commission.
Malkinson, who had previously demanded Pitcher’s removal from her position, criticized the timing of the apology, suggesting it was prompted by the CCRC’s exposure rather than genuine remorse. He highlighted the additional distress caused by the delay in acknowledgement and apology.
Furthermore, Malkinson asserted that Pitcher had dismissed criticisms of the CCRC’s actions when raised by his lawyer, indicating a lack of accountability within the organization.
He called for a change in leadership within the CCRC, advocating for individuals with empathy, humility, and a commitment to rectifying miscarriages of justice.
Drawing parallels to another case overturned by the Court of Appeal due to new DNA evidence, Malkinson’s legal team highlighted systemic flaws within the CCRC. An ongoing government inquiry seeks to address these issues and prevent similar injustices in the future.
Despite his dismissal, Malkinson’s struggles persist, as he lived in a tent on a campsite in Seville, Spain, due to financial constraints.
He awaits compensation for the years of wrongful imprisonment, emphasizing the ongoing impact of his ordeal on his life and well-being.
